A Gifted Man

By David Knox on January 25, 2012 / Filed Under Programming, Reviews 12

Neurosurgeon Dr. Michael Holt (Patrick Wilson) looks pretty darn perfect. He’s got the blue eyes, gleaming white teeth, a jogger’s physique, a sleek office and all the attitude of a giant pain in the butt.

Yes, Dr. Holt is a vanilla version of Dr. House.

He works in a swanky New York clinic with wealthy patients, plays grand piano in his apartment loft and snaps at all his clinic staff. You can do that when you’re as grossly successful as this.

One day in the middle of his autopilot, bachelor life he bumps into his ex-wife Anna (Jennifer Ehle) who he hasn’t seen in years. She surprises him by telling him she has moved to New York. They share a drink and remember the good times. He almost has a warm side.

Michael’s flighty sister Christina (Julie Benz) has a wayward teenage son Milo (Liam Aiken), the sum total of which is seemingly to complicate his life.

The key shift in A Gifted Man happens when Michael learns that Anna actually died two weeks before their chance meeting. The woman he thought he shared a drink with was either an hallucination or a visit from beyond. The rational doctor is thrown a curve ball. Literally in fact…

Christina, sometimes bordering on hysteria, is thrilled by the spiritual possibilities but when Michael has his second visitation his control on his life begins to unravel.

The ghostly Anna compels him to visit the public clinic where she used to work (yep, she worked in medicine too). Administering medical advice to single mothers with sick kids is worlds apart from Michael’s affluent office. By now it’s pretty obvious the arrogant doc is going to realise there is more to life, or death, than making money.

On screen, Anna has the same, full-bodied appearance as the other characters. Only Michael sees and talks to her, a fairly common convention in TV and movies. For a ghost series, I found it all a bit deja-vu.

As a leading man Wilson lacks character, swimming in earnest scenes and a plot-driven script. Benz is wasted in her supporting role (will she ever get a role as good as Dexter?). At least Margo Martindale as Michael’s motherly assistant Rita adds a bit of zest.

It’s somewhat surprising that Jonathan Demme (Silence of the Lambs, Philadelphia) is Producer of this drama, and Director of the first episode.

A Gifted Man is a mix of medical and supernatural drama but without enough of either to give it distinction. House was a wonderfully cranky doctor, Medium was a spooky spirit series, Spirited was an offbeat ghost tale. And Ghost was a downright hoot.

By the end of the episode I didn’t particularly care whether Dr. Michael found purpose to his single life or whether Anna crossed over to the other side (I’m tipping the premise requires her to hang around a bit longer).

But I think I would need at least one of those boxes ticked to come back for more.

A Gifted Man premieres 8pm Thursday on TEN.

12 Comments »

  1. tmorgan January 26, 2012 at 10:50 pm -

    When I saw the promo, I thought ‘Ghost Whisperer’ clone. And I hate that show.

  2. Rayne January 26, 2012 at 9:46 am -

    I’d rather watch this than any sort of reality rubbish! :)

  3. brisvegas January 25, 2012 at 3:34 pm -

    TNG ftw! :)

  4. Andrew B January 25, 2012 at 2:03 pm -

    A Gifted Man is certain to be cancelled as its ratings are well below all other CBS dramas. Also: Unforgettable is a likely candidate for cancellation, but not certain.

  5. Secret Squïrrel January 25, 2012 at 12:42 pm -

    Bland and unoriginal. A complete snorefest.

  6. Kathy January 25, 2012 at 11:53 am -

    I don’t get why Ten are screening this show on it’s main channel as I cannot see it being a ‘ratings’ winner for them. I for one will be very surprised if it survives.

    I also doubt it will get to a second season in the US.

  7. Jezza (the first original one) January 25, 2012 at 11:44 am -

    Thanks for the warning. I saw the promos and thought this looks like a crappy second rate US tv show and your review seems to confirm it. I will not watch and what is the betting that this gets shoved around the schedule….

  8. Allie January 25, 2012 at 11:33 am -

    Snooooozzzzzeeeeeee. Yet another “I see dead people” series. With a medical setting – zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Wake me when it’s over.

  9. Darren F January 25, 2012 at 10:49 am -

    I have seen the first 9 episodes and found that it does get better as it goes along. The spirit wife is seen less and the medical stories both at the clinic and his office become more the focus. Also the excellent Eric LaSalle (ER) and Rachelle Le Febvre (Twilight, Off The Map) come on board. Give it a go I say!

  10. JB January 25, 2012 at 9:34 am -

    Well I think it’s a good show. Sure it’s not the most amazing series but it’s good viewing compared to what’s out there. Plus anything with Patrick Wilson is worth watching. But apprently this looks to be cancelled in the US which i really don’t understand the US ratings system. It rates 8 million viewers which sounds good to me, it gets the most viewers in it’s timeslot, yet because of the way the ratings works in the US, this is said to rate poorly.

  11. A. January 25, 2012 at 7:57 am -

    Stupid timeslot again. ‘Cos even if I wanted to: I will watch ST The Next Gen at 8.30pm. By the way I never saw Julie Benz in Dexter but she was excellent in Buffy and Angel. Plus Jennifer Ehle was in the 1995 Mini-Series version of Pride and Prejudice as Elizabeth Bennett if I’m not mistaken.

  12. Bella January 25, 2012 at 5:16 am -

    Thanks for the review David. I was wondering what this show was about. Jennifer Ehle played Elizabeth Bennet in the BBC adaptation of Pride and Prejudice. (the one with Colin Firth)

Leave A Response »

You must be logged in to post a comment.