0/5

The Killing Field

Eve Winter's homicide squad flies in and out to solve a rural crime -but is it enough to sustain a telemovie?

Screen Shot 2014-05-01 at 9.31.26 pm.jpgWho doesn’t love a good whodunit?

Television is full of them whether as event dramas, weekly crimes or telemovies. The latest offering is The Killing Field, a Seven-produced telemovie featuring network sweetheart Rebecca Gibney (also acting as a Producer).

Neatly folding Julie Rafter away like a warm woolly jumper, she returns as the rather clinical and cool Detective Sergeant Eve Winter. She is lured by Detective Inspector Lachlan McKenzie (Peter O’Brien) back to a city-based Detective squad for a major case in the bush.

Joined by Detective Senior Constable Bridget Anderson (Chloé Boreham) and Detective Senior Constable Dan Wild (Liam McIntyre) they are confronted by the graves of five dead bodies in the fictional town of Mingara. While it suggests a serial killer has been hiding amongst the sleepy community, the more immediate threat concerns the disappearance of a teenage girl, Becky (Taylor Ferguson).

In their designer suits, this rather mod squad become fly-in, fly-out crime-busters (a nod to Criminal Minds perhaps?) openly discussing the case while strolling down main street. The local force, in over their heads, are left to mind the crime scene and can’t even seem to do that sufficiently.

We meet the family of the missing girl, and various townsfolk most of whom we would consider key suspects. The stock standard white board with photos is there to help. Eve serves as our guide into this world, gleaning pieces of information and raising suspicions about what’s been laying beneath the surface, literally, of Mingara.

She also suppresses an emotional backstory with McKenzie and there’s a little of the good cop / bad cop going on between them, thankfully not too heavily. Anderson and Wild have loosely-sketched backstories that will presumably develop should the drama proceed to series.

Supporting cast members include Damien Garvey, Darren Gilshenan, Anita Hegh and Dave Eastgate.

As a thriller you can expect red herrings, a little action and eleventh-hour jeopardy.

But aside from the handsome backdrop of the fictional Mingara this telemovie predominantly feels like a weekly episodic crime. It lacks the vast themes that would justify a telemovie format, and the depth of character required. Gibney has the cropped haircut and underplays the warmth with which she has become associated, but lacks the aggressive, seniority of a Helen Mirren Prime Suspect. 

Some policing moments feel amplified for drama rather than authenticity and we learn next to nothing of the other 5 victims or their families, who presumably live in the same town. The dialogue, too, slips into spelling out the obvious or signposting backstories.

“Mate this is a murder investigation, you have to tell us everything you know,” Wild barks at one point.

“Small town, small minds, redneck right-wing f***wits … this is why I left the country,” says Anderson at another point.

Indeed it’s roughly what I would expect if Seven were to parachute the City Homicide team into Mount Thomas, which is not to say this is not without a future, but perhaps one that gets to the point a little quicker at 42 minutes than 90.

Whether Eve Winter is enough for viewers to not long for Julie Rafter, or indeed Jane Halifax, to return is a mystery only the ratings will solve.

The Killing Field premieres 8:40pm Sunday on Seven.

14 Responses

  1. Watched the killing field and although did not find it riveting I enjoyed it and if they do make a series hope that has a little more ” umph”, agree that Peter O’Brien looked strange in someway, looked much older than his years.

  2. Seven were looking for a vehicle for Rebecca Gibney after the demise of Packed To The Rafters and they took this route despite other options. The writing was lazy and mediocre with little research or authenticity. The crime route is not the best choice for Rebecca Gibney who has great warmth and a flair for comedy. It is a shame her best talents won’t be utilised if it goes into series. And couldn’t they have put Peter O’Brien out in the sun for a minute. He looked like he needed a blood transfusion.

  3. I was looking forward to the movie and to the prospect of a series.Totally understand the lukewarm review. Nothing remotely like Prime Suspect, The Bridge, Halifax or even yes I say it Midsomer Murders! Sorry it’s a flop.

  4. Secret Squirrel, unless you’re a fan of Ms Gibney I’d say no.

    Mrs Prawn and I watched this last night and we weren’t impressed.

    It seemed a very amateurish production that could probably have done with a bit of input from an expert advisor, as there were just too many scenes where one had to suspend belief while watching. On about 5 different occasions I found myself saying “Surely that wouldn’t be allowed to happen…”

  5. This lukewarm review doesn’t inspire a great deal of confidence, particularly as you are such a huge supporter of Australian drama. The writer has hours of Blue Heelers and City Homicide credits so you’ve probably nailed that. As a launch for a potential series why didn’t they aim a little higher? The audience watches so much great crime drama it’s not enough to put up a derivative telemovie full of the usual tropes. Disappointed they didn’t continue to work outside the in-house approach like they did so successfully with INXS and the forthcoming Ivan Milat telemovie. There is no doubt the in-house drama approach has worked well for the past 3 decades – however I think Tim Worner is on the right track by backing a few new voices and taking a few drama risks.

  6. This looks dreadful & the awful song played over the ads does nothing for the show – I can’t decipher what she is singing about anyway.
    Rebecca Gibney peaked in The Flying Doctors for me (I never watched Rafters) so this is not for me. Peter O’Brien deserves better.

Leave a Reply