How Do You Solve a Problem like Maria?

By David Knox on January 6, 2010 / Filed Under Pay TV, Reviews 10

marLet’s get one thing straight. This UK reality series took place in 2006. So if you know the winner there isn’t much point going on with this series. If not, then you’re in for a bit of a camp olde tyme….

Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber has been so synonymous with popular entertainment that it really shouldn’t come as much surprise that even he, a pure thespian, should succumb to the lure of Reality Television to cast his next big thing: the role of Maria Von Trapp in The Sound of Music.

ALW of course didn’t write the score for this one, but he is (or was) producing a new production. It’s hard not to wonder what Rodgers & Hammerstein might make of the whole idea but if their estate -which is notorious in strict use of its works- has relented, then so be it.

Britain is seemingly full of young women who are all keen to skip the old fashioned method of hard chorus work, cattle calls and a stint at RADA if it means seeing their name in lights on the West End. They turn up in droves for these auditions: amateurs, first-timers and even ‘shop girls.’

On offer is a lifetime opportunity to play Maria Von Trapp in a way that Julie Andrews never delivered.

ALW reminds his hand-picked judges that he wants to believe his new Maria is a bit of a clown, a bit of a tomboy. “I want to believe she climbs a tree and scrapes her knee,” he insists. No room for nunnery here.

His judges include Producer David Ian, Vocal Coach Zoe Tyler and Actor John Barrowman (yes Torchwood fans, it’s a chance to see him in another light). They drill the girls through auditions, cutting them down to size with the quip, “You are not Maria!” or granting their dream with, “You could be Maria!”

I kept thinking “Gee it’s just as well they didn’t call this show ‘What Is It Maria You Can’t Face?’” -a somewhat notorious line of dialogue from the film that has wound its way into many comedy routines.

Holding our hand through it all is the effervescent Graham Norton, who feels every moment as the girls face those mean ole judges.

Like most audition shows, HDYSAPLM? can be car-crash telly. There are some rather talented discoveries, some disasters, some spirits crushed and some budding talents that you hope with a bit of nurturing might blossom into something. All of them make for entertaining storytelling.

Hovering above the whole thing is Sir ALW. He swoops in and out of the episode, taking time out from his other productions to check on progress. He is horrified by what he sees, which sees him become both ogre and saviour all at once. With his eccentric personality, and his awkward delivery, it all works a treat. Without someone like Simon Cowell on hand, ALW slips in perfectly.

With the success of The X Factor and Pop Idol, Britain ate up this show, rallying for its finalists and flocking to theĀ  performances and a new-found star. The entire marketing machine must have rolled over a glassy-eyed nation to perfection -so much so that ALW went on to cast productions of Joseph & The Amazing Technicolour Dreamcoat, Oliver!, and his Eurovision entry via television searches. This year he hunts for a new Dorothy (and her litle dog too) for The Wizard of Oz. Where will it all end?

Maybe next he could do a search for a new Composer?

3_starsHow Do You Solve a Problem Like Maria? airs 7:30pm Thursday on UKTV.

10 Comments »

  1. Mydoona January 8, 2010 at 9:57 pm -

    If your a ‘Wicked’ fan…Lucy Durack auditoned for this and never got past round one…how stupid are they over there? she is on the first episode for three secs about 13 minutes into the show.

  2. Brekkie January 7, 2010 at 10:22 am -

    LOL newtaste – funnily enough after a year off ALW & co. are back on the BBC to find a new Dorothy for The Wizard of Oz!

  3. Jack! January 6, 2010 at 5:22 pm -

    Damn! On bloody Pay TV!!! How unfair!
    Just wait until they show the next one … “Any Dream Will Do” where they are searching for the next Joseph … Barrowman and Norton are fabulous, the boys are “very talented” and Sir Andrew is a scream (in his own strange little way) it was a fantastic series!
    Jack!

  4. Craig H January 6, 2010 at 12:51 pm -

    word on the street has been that Gary Barlow is writing this years UK entry and that it will be preformed by former ‘Blue’ singer Duncan James (he presented the UKs points in last years contest) if both singer and song are selected by the BBC it will be the first time ever the UK hasnt held some kind of public vote to choose singer and / or Artist for EV. Given (as far as im aware) there has been no call for artists or songs for the UK yet, its lookig likely the BBC will be choosing something internally.

  5. David Knox January 6, 2010 at 11:51 am -

    Think I heard Gary Barlow was gonna give it a bash. ALW wouldn’t try again surely….

  6. Andrew January 6, 2010 at 11:42 am -

    slightly off-topic David but do you know if ALW is lending his expertise to the selction of the UK’s Eurovision entry again this year? Or what novel scheme has the UK got for selecting their act this year?? I saw some of Your Country Needs You last year in the UK but hadn’t heard if they were going down the same path this year.

  7. wamdue January 6, 2010 at 10:18 am -

    oh honestly, its a bit late for UKTV to be showing this, its years old.

    Whats next the first UK Big Brother?

  8. newtaste January 6, 2010 at 9:23 am -

    Maybe he could find a new ‘Dorothy’ for a new stage version of Tootsie.

  9. tomothy January 6, 2010 at 8:52 am -

    I thought this was an old show. I remember seeing the winner on The Graham Norton Christmas Special once. I think it was his 2007 Christmas Special. Old or new, Im not interested in it anyway.

  10. Ruth January 6, 2010 at 8:19 am -

    Ok, Great review David, I’m in for a look at this show as it sounds like it may be fun.
    Norton and Barrowman ??????? Very camp.

Leave A Response »

You must be logged in to post a comment.