Long haul for TEN as Breakfast starts in 4th place

By David Knox on February 24, 2012 / Filed Under News 29

The first day of TEN’s morning TV battle indicates the long haul ahead.

Launched with little fanfare due to the snap decision to begin 4 days ahead of schedule, Breakfast landed in fourth place.

Sunrise was 399,000.
Today was 348,000.
ABC News Breakfast was ABC1: 56,000 / ABC News 24: 26,000
Breakfast was 51,000.

There was also a separate figure of 46,000 for Breakfast “Early” from 6-7am. And 42,00 for Breakfast “Extended” post 9am.

Both Sunrise and Today also break out an “Early” figure for their first hour (216,000 / 170,000 respectively).

TEN has always maintained Breakfast is a long-haul project, and it was an achievement to get the show to air early with a news landscape that was changing minute by minute. But scoring a “0″ in Melbourne for 8:44-8:59am indicates just how tough the battle will be.

The real test will be in lifting shares from its former cartoon slots and attracting advertising revenue, and under the circumstances it’s too early to start drawing conclusions about results from the first day. A TEN release today claims a 67.8% increase in Total People.

Elsewhere last night My Kitchen Rules again ranked first with 1.63m viewers. Seven’s line-up once again led the night in all timeslots except at 7pm when ABC News won with 1.04m viewers.

Nine News was best for Nine on 922,000 followed by ACA on 813,000. Earth Flight was 557,000.

The Biggest Loser topped TEN’s evening on 709,000. Law and Order: SVU was 488,000 / 356,000. The Project was 411,000.

7:30 was 694,000 for ABC1. Family Confidential was 646,00 but The Straits was down to 456,000.

Neighbours topped multichannels on 278,000.

Thursday 23 February 2012.

29 Comments »

  1. Cookieboy February 26, 2012 at 5:22 pm -

    Based on the first two days. this show has a long way to grow. Great graphics, although hard to read the white on pink weather maximum temps; very odd set – including appalingly hokey backdrop with cartoon like rusted windmill. The man man, Paul Henry, looked most odd sandwiched betwwen the very tall Andrew Rochford. He also spent most of the show with a smarmy look on his face, as if he is above all of us. Not a good wash with everyday Aussies (even further plagued by the fact he is a Kiiwi…nothign wrong with that but not a great accent in the eyes of most Aussies…just saying it!) With almost 15 minutes of news and weather each time there wasn’t much scope for deeper stories. Seemed like a case of same old, same old…not much difference yet. So ratings result is hardly surprising and likely to stay there based on show 1 and 2.

  2. Casey February 25, 2012 at 1:10 pm -

    If Ten are serious about this and are in it for the long haul, then they’ve also got to have Saturday and Sunday versions of the show as well, with other hosts, not just have it on weekdays.

  3. Brekkie February 25, 2012 at 10:13 am -

    I don’t really understand the logic in launching a show the same as the other networks, just under different branding.

    Breakfast TV has unfortunately practically died out here in the UK over the last decade but in it’s heyday in the 90s you had very clear options – BBC Breakfast News for a more heavyweight start to the day, GMTV for a lightweight look at the news and The Big Breakfast if you preferred pure entertainment in the morning.

  4. jonno February 24, 2012 at 10:14 pm -

    The reality is that 10 are entering a very crowded but small market. It is a fierce market and 7,abc and 9 all produce quality and entertaining shows. Breakfast might be ok but to gain traction it has to be sensational. i am a rusted on sunrise viewer and Today have their rusted on viewers so Ten would probably do better if they just showed cartoons or the test pattern. They are just too late entering this market. If they had a point of difference they may do better but Breakfast is a poor imitation.

  5. steve sydney February 24, 2012 at 5:51 pm -

    @David Knox

    You know I too prefer the straight forward weather presentation but I think it’s a waste to have someone in studio only to have them on screen for 2 minutes every half hour. I’ve seen her do morning News updates and interaction with The Circle team doing so, prior to the launch of Breakfast so she obviously she is capable of alot more. Plus it would balance out the genders on that couch.

  6. David Knox February 24, 2012 at 4:58 pm -

    Magdalena is not a co-host, she is Weather Presenter and part of the team. Several readers have welcomed the weather presentation instead of funny guy approach.

  7. steve sydney February 24, 2012 at 4:57 pm -

    Perhaps they need to bring in a cash cow segment to lift the ratings??

    There are obviously alot of things to improve on like the set! Also why isn’t Magdalena being utilized? I thought she was a co host yet it appears she’s just there to look pretty and give the weather. Surely she has something to say?

    Hopefully they’ll find a groove and have decent guest interviews happening along with presenting worth while stories and segment. I do love the lack of sport updates however..

  8. ryan February 24, 2012 at 4:34 pm -

    Ten showed gillard live today and 7 and 9 didnt even show it

  9. Bogues February 24, 2012 at 4:32 pm -

    Ten have had a really bad start with just under half of the population living outside the AEDT timezone. Why they didn’t go live to all states like Sunrise and Today have done over the past two days is beyond belief.

    If they want to start early because of the Labor leadership, surely they would know that the needed to go live to all states and terottiries.

  10. Rowie February 24, 2012 at 4:16 pm -

    In regards to the pic, do they mean Julie Bishop…not Julia Bishop??

  11. BigVic February 24, 2012 at 4:12 pm -

    Wow!!! Won’t be watching anymore and no wonder Sunrise is my favourite breakfast program. Heard that WS has been thumping Today since its relaunch.

  12. lin February 24, 2012 at 3:49 pm -

    The Kevin Rudd press conference was live on Sunrise and Today, but on Breakfast there was no sign of it. Half an hour later when I flipped over there were headlines on screen saying the Rudd press conference was just about to start. I must be a bit slow, but only then did I realise the show was on half an hour delay in Adelaide! They also need to get rid of the coffee table!

  13. Ry February 24, 2012 at 3:45 pm -

    How can they not have a Sports Presenter?! Wasn’t Brad McEwan originally meant to be apart of the team?

  14. Casey February 24, 2012 at 3:41 pm -

    The cartoons could be moved over to Eleven at the same timeslot, where all Eleven are currently showing then, are repeats of ancient US shows.

  15. doreen February 24, 2012 at 3:32 pm -

    What I saw of Breakfast didn’t enjoy but it’s only day one. Quite enjoyed Paul, Andrew was constantly drinking coffee. Switched back to Sunrise and must say Mel is great out of the studio and thought she did a great job.

  16. ausriley26 February 24, 2012 at 2:00 pm -

    I’m glad Breakfast came last. It was identical to Sunrise and Today, despite 10′s promises. I think I’ll stick with ABC News Breakfast and Today.

  17. JB February 24, 2012 at 1:33 pm -

    Shame about The Straits. It’s a pretty good show. FNQ looks amazing, good to see a show set somewhere besides dirty old Melbourne.

    Sucked in to Ten’s Breakfast. Sack Henry, i might watch, but ABC News Breakfast is far superior to them all. Although if Kochie wears a Port Adelaide scarf every day like this morning, i might switch back to Sunrise.

  18. Craig February 24, 2012 at 1:09 pm -

    What annoyed me today is they knew Rudd was going to be having a live press thing this morning but here in QLD we have to wait an hour to see the ‘live’ coverage on TEN. One day is understandable on a brand new show but surely they could have just started it her at 5am QLD time to have live for local viewers.

  19. db February 24, 2012 at 12:20 pm -

    The format is going to do them in. There’s no point in serving up different hosts in such a similar style to the other two. I understand the urge to tap into such a rich market, but they need to something different and talking about what’s happening on Twitter isn’t it. Anyone who wants to know what’s on Twitter is on Twitter. What would have been great is a melange of Video Hits, The Couch, Before the Game, Entertainment Tonight with a sprinkling of news/current affairs.

  20. cglenn1988 February 24, 2012 at 12:06 pm -

    Sunrise did start with under 100k and the book Who Killed Channel 9 did say something about Sunrise when Adam Borland took over and I think it was getting an average of about 91k and Today was over 400k. Ch 7 used to air cartoons like Ten did and ch 10 once had a popular breakfast show in the 80s and early 90s. Ten need to commit to Breakfast on the long term and let it grow. Seven let Sunrise grew and look at its ratings now and over the past 7 years. Maybe Breakfast will end up as Australia’s number 1 breakfast show. Sunrise did it so its possible for breakfast. Breakfast did launch unexpectedly with little promotion for yesterday’s start.

    At least The Circle will have a stronger lead in and the kids will still watch the same cartoons just over on 11 instead.

  21. JoshM February 24, 2012 at 11:31 am -

    I did not see Breakfast today, but yesterday the sudden change in programming was very obvious – almost all of the adds were for toys. Im sure there will be some very unhappy advertisers who had paid for a under 15 audience and did not get it.

  22. Kenny February 24, 2012 at 11:04 am -

    And, as an example of lack of credibility, her name is Julie Bishop, not “Julia”.
    ” A TEN release today claims a 67.8% increase in Total People”. Yeah, well, from 2 to 3.4 is 67.8% so depends on the base figure to have any meaning.

  23. Guy February 24, 2012 at 10:57 am -

    Breakfast had no advertising what so ever. I expected low ratings and it got it. Sunrise was very good yesterday. Mel when she is out of the studio is very good.

  24. Mr Rampage February 24, 2012 at 10:53 am -

    Wasn’t George Negus a long-haul project too?

  25. Jennome February 24, 2012 at 10:50 am -

    I’m not sure why Australia needs another TV show at breakfast. I don’t watch any of them, TV during the daytime is not something we’ve ever done, I stick with radio during the day. However you have to hand it to TEN who seem willing to do far more experimentation than the others, who play it safe to the point of total exasperation.

    Good for them for sticking with The Project (so far!) – I’ve watched it from the beginning.

  26. Dodge February 24, 2012 at 10:37 am -

    It will get better but, let’s not kid ourselves, it’s not going to get anywhere near Today or Sunrise. And because of this, I can see the producers urging Paul to say something controversial to get more ratings, but that’s another issue.

  27. Anthony Mai February 24, 2012 at 10:27 am -

    Wow, SVU just keeps dropping every season! I actually really enjoyed yesterday’s episode with Sofia Vassilieva.

  28. James February 24, 2012 at 10:27 am -

    Bye bye breakfast

  29. Beckala February 24, 2012 at 10:25 am -

    One issue Ten has is that a lot of the advertising of the new Breakfast is still indicating that the program hasn’t started yet – listening to Nova 969 yesterday afternoon they had the show sponsoring the news, but it was still presented as “starting Monday” – so if you had missed the Project’s announcement or hadn’t noticed it in the news then you wouldn’t be aware that it had already started. I’d wait til next week before really judging it – my husband for example had no idea it had moved until I mentioned it when I heard the ad on Nova.

Leave A Response »

You must be logged in to post a comment.