Axed: Australia’s Got Talent

By David Knox on April 4, 2014 / Filed Under News, Top Stories 39

AGT20217It was pretty obvious that when Nine did not confirm a return for Australia’s Got Talent at its 2014 Upfronts that the show would not be returning.

Networks don’t like to put out bad news at a time when they are pushing good.

But today Mumbrella has reported, officially, that the show is over.

Earlier this year Nine Programmer Andrew Backwell told TV Tonight, “We still have it under option with the ability to trigger it. We’re not going to let it go quite yet. We’ll see how The Voice launches and I think it will be big.”

It’s been a rollercoaster ride for the show. In 2011 it was a blockbuster, with ratings of over 2 million on Seven.

In 2012 Nine killed its chances when it was programmed against The Voice. As a result Seven decided not to renew it, allowing Nine to swoop on it for 2013.

But the tables were reversed. This time Seven killed it with The X Factor, a show produced by the same production company, FremantleMedia Australia.

Late last year Nine confirmed it would produce two versions of The Voice in 2014, announcing The Voice Kids. That pretty much sealed its fate. It’s too risky to try and squeeze three talent shows on one network in one year and AGT has had to make way.

Unless TEN or Foxtel miraculously come to its rescue it would seem AGT is over for many years.

In its 7 year life span it has, however, managed to uncover or elevate some entertainment acts: Justice Crew, Jack Vidgen, Timomatic (who went from contestant to judge), Cosentino and Mark Vincent but also seen its judges attract just as much attention behind the scenes.

39 Comments »

  1. marc April 12, 2014 at 6:29 pm -

    Oh no! Where to put all the UK staff now???

  2. once-upon-a-time April 6, 2014 at 8:52 pm -

    Seems that abbreviations are all the go in so many of these comments.

    AGT, TFX, SYTYCD, MKR,FMA;US,UK.

    So it seems that it is only a natural progression for Network Ten to pick up AGT, as Ten seems to have assumed the duties of the TV Lands Media Coroner and even branched out into the realms of an UFEVPP (Undertaker For Even Very Popular Programmes).

    Probably Tens next natural progression is to prefix many of its EPG programmes and replace the misused ‘ Encore’ ( audience request) with a TFNITC classification ( The Final Nail In The Coffin), at least they can then claim they have nailed something.

  3. AEDDIE April 6, 2014 at 4:47 pm -

    I’ve never seen AGT, but I do hope TEN pick it up.

  4. peejaybee April 6, 2014 at 12:59 pm -

    Let’s not forget that 9 struck first when programming The Voice up against AGT. 7 were well within their rights to counter program with X Factor…

  5. DanR April 6, 2014 at 8:41 am -

    Could it be a good Saturday night show for Ten?

  6. emurray April 6, 2014 at 4:35 am -

    Maybe pay a bit less for judges and put it on Saturday night and it becomes a point of difference for nine against footy on seven and abc and would help nines overall ratings for week

  7. toddt85 April 5, 2014 at 5:07 pm -

    Highly unsurprising news. When 7 did the dodgy and put X Factor up against AGT, I knew AGT would come off worse for wear. I did prefer the newer 9 version, but the $$$ poured into it for such average ratings clearly didn’t justify its renewal by 9. The best thing would be for it to be rested for a few years and then brought back, ala Big Brother.

  8. trustno1 April 5, 2014 at 12:12 pm -

    Just a slight clarification. The programme wasn’t axed. It was “boned”.

  9. Jennome April 5, 2014 at 11:38 am -

    Thank goodness, one less talent show. Not that I ever watch any of them, but at least – hopefully – it frees up time for more decent drama, and not yet another reality show. I’ve almost abandoned the commercial networks, the stuff they’re throwing at us is truly dreadful.

    SBS has some fabulous programming, if only people took the time to suss it out.

  10. MM April 5, 2014 at 10:18 am -

    AGT was funny and different in the beginning but after a few seasons a lot of it was stupid, seven did the right thing to let it go, nine thought they could re-vamp it but don’t know what happened to the re-vamp as there was very little difference than on seven, hence the show did not do any better than in the latter years on seven as it had already run its race anyway, so let bygones’ be bygones’.

  11. carol April 5, 2014 at 7:36 am -

    We are talent show watchers as they are good fodder for a family with young kids (SYTYCD is a current fave here). However, we have never watched AGT due to Kyle Sandliands. I refuse to expose my kids to him.

  12. chivasssimo April 4, 2014 at 11:38 pm -

    I’ve always thought the show suffer from being a “mismatch” of skills – some which can’t really be a viable project to pursue (not saying people aren’t talented, just that there’s better shows out there). Besides, we get the voice kids instead…,yuck. Please put that against X factor so it can be axed too,

  13. oztvheritage April 4, 2014 at 11:17 pm -

    I never really watched it….was a glorified Red Faces really…..but would be a good pick up for TEN. But sounds like Nine will hang onto the rights for a while.

    Hopefully with Nine paying big money for NRL and Cricket rights…. Ten will have money to invest in some big new and shinny reality show from the international stage. Surely there is somethiing new and exciting out there. Ten’s needs “a new The Voice” and quickly!

  14. Darwinite April 4, 2014 at 10:52 pm -

    Bring back Red as host, he gave really honest opinions and didn’t get suckered in by kids.

    Ever since they got rid of Red and Tom it always seems to be music based people getting the nod rather than novelty type acts. However I cannot forget that Bonnie who was a singer won on one of Red’s seasons.

    Brian who was supposed to be a judge, cheated on Hey Hey’s Red faces when he tried to give a minus score on a great act just for a little 4 year old kid to win.

    Kyle and Tim have been quite annoying also, Tim especially, he mustn’t remember he was on this show too.

    Watched America’s got talent on cable the last few years, Australia’s version is so amateurish compared to theirs, so I am not surprised to hear this news that this show has been canned.

  15. a_twit April 4, 2014 at 10:34 pm -

    Ten will want Australia’s Got Talent. If the show can manage to rate over 700,000, Ten will be happy.

  16. amanda_20 April 4, 2014 at 9:37 pm -

    I never watched it. Had a feeling it was going.

  17. David Knox April 4, 2014 at 9:04 pm -

    My memory is that Nine revealed their timeslot before Seven revealed AGT.

  18. Guy April 4, 2014 at 8:59 pm -

    @The Moops
    Thanks. I remember it was a band but personally didn’t think they were any good.

    @MrJ
    It was Channel 9 who killed the show not Fremantle or anyone else. It was them who decided to throw it against the hit that is The X Factor. If they played it mid-week it may have done better. Its not like MKR and The Block which have different audiences. Talent shows seem to have a similar audience and usually the one with the best talent comes out on top which is what happened last year in which i think was The X Factor’s best year to date.

  19. ilovetv April 4, 2014 at 8:51 pm -

    Never liked it so glad it’s gone.

  20. David Knox April 4, 2014 at 8:39 pm -

    Mr J: Networks make promos not production companies. AGT and TXF even shared the same director, making the best possible product for both.

  21. The Moops April 4, 2014 at 8:18 pm -

    @Guy, Uncle Jed, a trio from Melbourne, won AGT last year.

  22. Phil April 4, 2014 at 8:00 pm -

    10 needs this show!! Kyle and Timomatic need to go. Timomatic hasn’t even sold records for him to be a judge to others. Kyle needs to leave TV altogether. Julia Morris should continue as host and the male judges should be Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr. American Idol is on the verge of being cancelled so this could be great to fill their time. 10 should also air this at the same time in the year as MKR and The Block but in terms of what time they have the show the time should be straight after 10 news and have it for an hour and a half. The Project could then move to 11 and be on before neighbours at 6 o clock and air for 30 minutes.

  23. billy66683 April 4, 2014 at 8:00 pm -

    I am curious as to why they dropped this it did average around 1 million isn’t that a decent number?

  24. Mr. J April 4, 2014 at 7:59 pm -

    might be worth 9’s while to investigate if there was any tanking from fremantle. Surely it was in their best interest to protect the golden goose, The X Factor, even if it meant throwing AGT in front of a bus.
    It did seem to me that they were not trying at all, usually you can see a certain passion in FMA’s production and especially in their promotions.

  25. catherine April 4, 2014 at 6:52 pm -

    Wasnt nine gloating a year ago how well it was rating and having a crack at 7 for letting it go?

    I guess 9 wrecked it because it used to do well for 7 well in the early days anyway. So no more geri or kyle

  26. Shoudy Chen April 4, 2014 at 6:37 pm -

    Told you that AGT will not come back on Nine. Channel Nine made a good decision not to renew this show because it was a massive flop. Didn’t survive against rivals – The X factor.
    That’s why Nine doesn’t have any talent anymore.

  27. Dave April 4, 2014 at 6:31 pm -

    9 know when to bail. 10 however

  28. Dr.Karl Stefaknowvic April 4, 2014 at 6:08 pm -

    New shows set to debut in US and UK make this and X Factor look very tired. A change is coming…

  29. Mr. J April 4, 2014 at 6:02 pm -

    @veritas, incorrect. The show was almost axed in 2009 pre-Kyle, then he came on board in 2010 and the show became a huge hit, it was the #1 show of 2011.

    Also the episode after Kyle was fired from idol ratings bombed and it was consequently axed, almost the exact same scenario happened in Sydney radio. Love or hate Kyle, his rating power is undeniable.

  30. harrypotter1994 April 4, 2014 at 6:01 pm -

    I watched every season on 7 and also bits of the Nine series and have got to say the format is the killer here. Think for example you only see the winner in about 4 or 5 episodes of the whole show – not really enough to really sell yourself to the general public who tune into a few eps every known again.

  31. David Knox April 4, 2014 at 5:58 pm -

    Veritas sorry but that’s just a bit of a rewriting of history. Kyle had 3 seasons with Seven including when the show had ratings of over 2 million. You’re also attributing its performance to one individual rather than the panel, the level of talent and, specifically, the competition airing against it.

  32. Mr. J April 4, 2014 at 5:51 pm -

    I think it was salvageable after 2012, but it needed atleast 18 months off air and to come back refreshed, a Feb 2014 start would have done it a lot of justice.
    Instead it only took 12 months off and returned looking dated and daggy.

  33. Guy April 4, 2014 at 5:50 pm -

    It looks like Nine still has the rights to the show but are not bringing it out in 2014. A bit like Seven has done with The Amazing Race Australia. I must say though the talent last season was pretty average and i can’t even remember who won. I was too focused on The X Factor.

  34. Veritas April 4, 2014 at 5:43 pm -

    As soon as Kyle Sandilands became a judge on Seven’s version of AGT the ratings went down and it was axed. Nine picked it up and put Kyle back in the judge’s chair. Now it’s been axed again. I can’t help thinking that if Nine had taken the opportunity to bypass Kyle and get all new judges the program might still be running.

  35. Daniel April 4, 2014 at 5:28 pm -

    Ten would be wise to pick this up. It is certainly less risky then launching a brand new show.

    The network needs a big entertainment format like this, so I’d definitely try and give this a go.

  36. Josh777 April 4, 2014 at 5:03 pm -

    I have never watched it so can’t comment on the basis of it’s axing based on its content, but to see two Simon Cowell series go head to head was a stupid move, not to mention two Fremantle Australia produced series, as all it does is undercut each other meaning one has to give. But in saying that I am glad that this means one less reality series on our screens.

  37. gregaus April 4, 2014 at 5:01 pm -

    So the cynic (or is that the ‘realist’) in me thinks that Nine bought the franchise in order to kill it off. Giving it one go, just one season, makes no sense.

  38. CraigW April 4, 2014 at 4:59 pm -

    It’s a real shame for Lady JMo because I think she’s undervalued a bit. I hope she gets other projects.

  39. JennyW April 4, 2014 at 4:59 pm -

    “We’re not going to let it go quite yet.” Meaning they don’t want Ten to get it. AGT could just be what Ten needs.

Leave A Response »

You must be logged in to post a comment.